The Leadership Pipeline: Why Your Best Performers Might Not Be Your Best Leaders

High performance doesn't equal high potential. Yet most organisations promote their strongest individual contributors into leadership roles and wonder why they struggle. Explore why leadership gaps build, the visual framework that works to see where your leaders are on the map, and what separates organisations with leadership depth from those facing succession crises in our Signature Leadership Breakfast Series Recap.

Leadership pipelines don’t happen by accident. They reflect what leaders are willing to prioritise. Yet, many organisations discover their pipeline only when a gap appears. By then, it’s  far too late to close it. 

This guide draws on the Signature Breakfast Series workshop with Shaun Durham, of Crisp Professional Development, and explores practical commitments to building a pipeline that creates leadership depth, not leadership gaps. 

What Is Leadership? 

Leadership is notoriously hard to define. As Ralph Stogdill famously noted, “There are almost as many definitions of leadership as there are persons who have attempted to define the concept.” 

Yet there’s something unmistakable about it. Warren Bennis put it another way: “Leadership is like beauty: it’s hard to define, but you know it when you see it.” 

"Think of the best leader you've worked for. What made them ready for that role?"

The answer matters. Because leaders don’t arrive ready. They are developed intentionally. 

That intentionality is what separates organisations that have leadership depth from those facing a crisis of succession. 

 

What Is a Leadership Pipeline? 

A leadership pipeline is a deliberate system for identifying, developing, and transitioning people through increasing levels of leadership responsibility. 

Leadership gaps don’t appear suddenly; they build quietly through overlooked mentoring conversations, missed developmental opportunities, or roles filled reactively rather than strategically. A leadership pipeline is about reducing that risk deliberately. 

Two Models, Two Contexts 

The Traditional Pipeline Model (Charan, Drotter & Noel, 2001) assumes a linear hierarchy: progression up the ranks, with leadership tied to promotions and formal authority. Think of a typical finance career path: from Accounts Junior to Senior, then to Management Accountant, Financial Controller, and Director. 

This model assumes: 

  • Clear, defined roles at each level 
  • One path upwards 
  • Leadership = formal authority 
  • Organisations remain relatively stable 

 

The Squiggly Career Model (Helen Tupper & Sarah Ellis, 2020) reflects how careers actually work today: non-linear, fluid, values-driven, and self-directed. Leadership opportunities arise through lateral moves, projects, cross-functional influence — not just promotions. 

This model recognises: 

  • Careers are personalised and often zig-zag 
  • Skills matter more than titles 
  • People want alignment with purpose, not just security 
  • Leaders take responsibility for their own development 

 

These models are not mutually exclusive. The most effective organisations draw on both: they maintain clarity on hierarchy and progression (traditional), while creating space for lateral moves, projects, and values-driven development (squiggly). 

Why Pipelines Fail 

Most organisations have no formal pipeline at all. Those that do often fail silently and then suddenly all at once, when a leader leaves and there’s no one ready to step in.  

Common Failure Points:   

  • Promoting performance, not potential. The best technical person becomes the worst manager. We mistake yesterday’s success for tomorrow’s readiness. 
  • No clarity on what leadership means at each level. People can’t develop towards a standard they can’t see. Ambiguity kills pipelines. 
  • Over-reliance on training courses. You can’t develop leaders in a classroom. Courses support development; they don’t create it. 
  • No succession visibility. If no one knows who could step in, no one is being prepared to. 
  • Leaders hoarding responsibility. When senior leaders won’t let go, emerging leaders never get exposure to real complexity and risk. 

 

Cultural Blockers 

When asked what the biggest cultural blocker to developing leaders is, consistent answers emerge: 

  • Short-term pressure 
  • Billable targets 
  • Leaders afraid to let go 
  • No time for coaching 

 

These are clues, not excuses. They tell you where the pipeline has to start: with senior leadership committing that development is not optional. 

Performance vs. Potential: The 9-Box Grid 

Here’s where many pipelines go wrong: high performance does not equal high potential. 

Performance is how well someone delivers now. Potential is their capacity to operate at a higher level of complexity in the future. 

Strong Performance Indicators 

  • Consistent results 
  • Values alignment 
  • Sustained delivery 

 

Strong Leadership Potential Indicators 

  • Learning agility: Learns quickly from experience; adapts readily. 
  • Systems thinking: Sees beyond their own role; understands the wider business. 
  • Influence beyond authority: Can align others without formal power. 
  • Resilience under pressure: Handles ambiguity and setbacks well. 
  • Motivation for greater responsibility: Actually wants leadership and not just the status.

"Potential is about scale — can this person operate effectively at the next level of complexity?"

The 9-Box Grid: A Visual Framework 

Many organisations mistakenly promote the best performer, the longest-serving person, or the most visible person. The 9-box grid helps visualise the gap between performance and potential: 

The 9-Box: Who Goes Where
High PotentialMedium PotentialLow Potential
High PerformanceStar / Future LeaderStrong ContributorExpert / Specialist
Medium PerformanceEmerging TalentCore PerformerInconsistent
Low PerformanceMisplaced TalentUnderperformerPerformance Issue

Common Grid Mistakes to Avoid 

Inflating everyone: No one wants to label someone “low potential.” The grid becomes meaningless when no one appears in that box. 

Confusing loyalty with potential: Tenure is not the same as future leadership capacity. 

Using it as a labelling tool rather than a development guide: The grid’s value is in triggering conversations about growth, not in sorting people. 

Making it an HR exercise: If line leaders aren’t debating talent, the grid has no value.  

Assessing Your High-Potentials 

Are you assessing potential based on yesterday’s leadership model? 

Before you label someone as high-potential and invest in their development, ask yourself: could they lead in the environment they’ll face, not the one that exists today? 

Your high-potentials should be able to: 

  • Lead effectively in ambiguity 
  • Lead a hybrid team 
  • Make ethical trade-offs 
  • Challenge upwards constructively 

These questions push beyond the traditional “Is this person smart, ambitious, and well-liked?” Instead, they reveal whether someone can handle the complexity of leadership in 2030. 

Five Commitments to Take Away

Looking to hire? We’ll call you back.

If you’re looking to hire, pop in your details and we’ll give you a callback to chat through your hiring needs in more detail.

OR

Looking to get hired? Search jobs

Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience. By continuing to use the site, you consent to the use of cookies for essential functionality and analytics purposes.